Year One (PG-13 for some strong profanity, comic violence, plenty of crude & sexual content)
Harold Ramis has been writing or directing films like "National Lampoon's Animal House," "Meatballs," "Caddyshack, both "Ghostbusters," and what I feel is his masterpiece, "Groundhog Day." "Year One" is a giant step down, expressing the worst of his now celebrated use of sloppiness and improvisation in an anything-goes, slap-dash attitude.
Jack Black is Zed, a lazy talker, coupled with Michael Cera's bland, throw-away pal Oh. Together they take off to see the world, traveling from one random scene to another - scenes that bear the slightest lift from biblical tales; they experience the encounter between Cain & Able, meet Abraham in the nick of time to save his son Isaac they save him, not God; that's as far as the filmmakers want to go with biblical accuracy), find pleasure in Sodom before its demise, etc., etc. - none of each scene more than a sketch improvised in Saturday Night Live style. Each sketch - excuse me, I mean scene - begins without much formality and is casually dropped when the cast runs out of things to say or do. It's an exasperating device that is only as good as the improve is good, which is not very often.
Harold Raimis, Gene Stupnitsky & Lee Eisenberg scripted this from one of Raimis' original ideas. Raimis directs with occasional spurts of inspiration, but hardly enough; mainly he seems to be sleepwalking through it, sloppiness and all. He, Judd Apatow & Clayton Townsend co-produced.
As I read the credits, I could hardly believe there actually was a script that included written dialog. But the humor - based, as usual on scatological, juvenile nudge-nudge, snick-snickiness is easily recognized as having been the product of the team (including members of the Raimis/Apatow ensemble: Paul Rudd et al). Any fan of their juvenile brand of humor, which includes burlesque-style sexual innuendo, vomiting, breaking wind, plenty of direct reference to genitals, and eating warm poop will love it. For the rest of us it's 97-minutes of excruciating disappointment. more Enjoy, instead, watching once again the Mel Brooks treatment of similar, much better, material in his "History of the World, Part One." Now, that's classic comedy for you.
Archived Movie Reviews
August 2009
- JULIE AND JULIA (A-)
- G.I. JOE: THE RISE OF COBRA (B-)
- INGLOURIOUS BASTERDS (B)
- SHORTS (B)
- POST GRAD (F)
July 2009
- MY SISTER'S KEEPER (C+)
- TRANSFORMERS 2: REVENGE OF THE FALLEN (D)
- PUBLIC ENEMIES (B+)
- ICE AGE 3: DAWN OF THE DINOSAURS (C+)
- BRUNO (D+)
- HARRY POTTER & THE HALF-BLOOD PRINCE (A-)
- ORPHAN (B-)
- THE UGLY TRUTH (D+)
- G-FORCE (F+)
June 2009
- UP (A)
- DRAG ME TO HELL (B-)
- THE HANGOVER (C+)
- LAND OF THE LOST (D+)
- THE TAKING OF PELHAM 1 2 3 (B)
- IMAGINE THAT (D+)
- The Proposal (B-)
- Year One (D)
May 2009
- STAR TREK (2009) (A-)
- ANGELS & DEMONS (B-)
- Earth (B+)
- NIGHT AT THE MUSEUM 2 (B)
- TERMINATOR 4 (D+)
- DANCE FLICK (D-)
April 2009
- FAST & FURIOUS - #4 (C+)
- HANNAH MONTANA THE MOVIE (B-)
- OBSERVE & REPORT (D+)
- DRAGONBALL: EVOLUTION (Grade: F)
- STATE OF PLAY (B+)
- 17 AGAIN (C-)
March 2009
- THE UNINVITED (B-)
- NEW IN TOWN (F)
- REVOLUTIONARY ROAD (A)
- WATCHMEN (B-)
- DEFIANCE (C+)
- DUPLICITY (B-)
- I LOVE YOU, MAN (C-)
- KNOWING (C-)
- CONFESSIONS OF A SHOPAHOLIC (F)
- MONSTERS VS. ALIENS (B-)
- THE HAUNTING IN CONNECTICUT (C+)
- 12 ROUNDS (C-)
- THE LAST HOUSE ON THE LEFT (F)
February 2009
- TAKEN (C+)
- GRAN TORINO (C)
- DOUBT (B-)
- PUSH (B)
- HE'S JUST NOT THAT INTO YOU (C-)
- THE PINK PANTHER 2 (D)
- THE INTERNATIONAL (B-)
- FRIDAY THE 13th (F)
- SLUMDOG MILLILONAIRE (A-)
- FIRE UP (D)
January 2009
- BRIDE WARS (C-)
- MY BLOODY VALENTINE (C+)
- HOTEL FOR DOGS (C+)
- PAUL BLART: MALL COP (C-)
- INKHEART (C)
- UNDERWORLD: RISE OF THE LYCANS (C-)
- THE UNBORN (D-)
December 2008
- AUSTRALIA (B+)
- FOUR CHRISTMASES (F)
- PUNISHER: WAR ZONE (D-)
- THE CHANGELING (A-)
- THE DAY THE EARTH STOOD STILL, 2008 (D+)
- SEVEN POUNDS (B-)
- YES MAN (D+)
- TRANSPORTER 3 (D)
- THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON (A)
- VALKYRIE (B+)
- THE TALE OF DESPEREAUX (A-)
- MARLEY & ME (D+)
- SPIRIT (D)
November 2008
- W (A-)
- MADAGASCAR II - ESCAPE TO AFRICA (C-)
- ROLE MODELS (D-)
- QUANTUM OF SOLAS (C+)
- BOLT (B)
- TWILIGHT (C+)
October 2008
- BEVERLY HILLS CHIHUAHUA (C+)
- QUARANTINE (D+)
- MAX PAYNE (C-)
- BURN AFTER READING (B+)
- HIGH SCHOOL MUSICAL 3: SENIOR YEAR (C+)
- SAW 5 (F-)
September 2008
- BANGKOK DANGEROUS (C+)
- DEATH RACE (D+)
- VICKI CRISTINA BARCELONA (B)
- TRAITOR (B-)
- MY BEST FRIEND'S GIRL (F)
- RIGHTEOUS KILL (B-)
- EAGLE EYE (C-)
- NIGHTS IN RODANTHE (D)
August 2008
- THE MUMMY: TOMB OF THE DRAGON EMPEROR (D)
- SWING VOTE (C)
- THE SISTEROOD OF THE TRAVELING PANTS 2 (C+)
- PINEAPPLE EXPRESS (C-)
- TROPIC THUNDER (B+)
- MIRRORS (C-)
- THE ROCKER (C)
- THE CLONE WARS (D)
July 2008
- WALL-E (A)
- WANTED (D+)
- HANCOCK (A-)
- HELLBOY II: THE GOLDEN ARMY (B+)
- JOURNEY TO THE CENTER OF THE EARTH - in 3D (C+)
- MEET DAVE (D+)
- THE DARK KNIGHT (A-)
- MAMA MIA! (B-)
- SPACE CHIMPS (B)
- STEP BROTHERS (D+)
- THE X-FILES: I WANT TO BELIEVE (D)
June 2008
- SEX IN THE CITY (B-)
- KUNG FU PANDA (A-)
- YOU DON'T MESS WITH THE ZOHAN (D)
- THE INCREDIBLE HULK (C+)
- THE STRANGERS (D+)
- THE HAPPENING (D)
- GET SMART (B-)
- THE LOVE GURU (D)
May 2008
March 2008
- DR. SEUSS' HORTON HEARS A WHO (B)
- PENELOPE (B)
- NEVER BACK DOWN (C-)
February 2008
- The Eye (C)
- Meet the Spartans (F)
- Fool's Gold (D)
- Sweeney Todd (A)
- The Spiderwick Chronicles (B)
- Jumper (C)
- Welcome Home, Roscoe Jenkins (C)
- Untraceable (D+)
- Joe's Long List of Long Movies (A)
January 2008
- JUNO (B+)
- ONE MISSED CALL (D-)
- THE WATER HORSE: LEGEND OF THE DEEP (B+)
- ALIENS VS. PREDATOR: REQUIEM (none)
- BUCKET LIST (B+)
- FIRST SUNDAY (C+)
- NO COUNTRY FOR OLD MEN (A)
- 27 DRESSES (C+)
- CLOVERFIELD (C+)
- MAD MONEY (D)
- Atonement (A)
- John Rambo (C+)
December 2007
- AWAKE (none)
- THE GOLDEN COMPASS (C)
- I AM LEGEND (B-)
- ALVIN & THE CHIPMUNKS (D)
- Charlie Wilson's War (B-)
- NATIONAL TREASURE: BOOK OF SECRETS (C+)
November 2007
- GONE BABY GONE (A-)
- American Gangster (A-)
- Bee Movie (B-)
- ACROSS THE UNIVERSE (C+)
- FRED CLAUS (C-)
- ENCHANTED (A-)
- DAN IN REAL LIFE (B)
- The Mist (C-)
- HITMAN (D-)
- MICHAEL CLAYTON (A-)
- BEOWULF (B-)
- MR. MAGORIUM'S WONDER EMPORIUM (D)
October 2007
- The Kingdom (B-)
- Dragon Wars (D)
- The Game Plan (D)
- The Heartbreak Kid (C)
- Sydney White (D-)
- The Seeker (none)
- We Own the Night (B-)
- 30 Days of Night (B)
- The Nightmare Before Christmas (3D Version) (B+)
- The Ten Commandments (D)
- The Comebacks (none)
- WHY DID I GET MARRIED? (C)
September 2007
- Balls of Fury (C-)
- War (C-)
- Halloween (D+)
- 3:10 to Yuma (B+)
- The Brave One (A-)
- Becoming Jane (B)
- Mr. Woodcock (D)
- Resident Evil: Extinction (D)
- Good Luck, Chuck (F)
August 2007
- The Bourne Ultimatum (A-)
- Underdog (C+)
- Hot Rod (C-)
- Stardust (B)
- Rush Hour 3 (D)
- I Know Who Killed Me (D-)
- Daddy Day Care (F-)
- Superbad (B-)
- No Reservations (B-)
- Invasion (D)
- The Nanny Diaries (C)
July 2007
- Ratatouille (A)
- Live Free or Die Hard (B+)
- Transformers (B-)
- Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix (B+)
- Hairspray (A-)
- I Now Pronounce You Chuck and Larry (D-)
- The Simpson's Movie (A-)
June 2007
- Hot Fuzz (B+)
- Knocked Up (C)
- Mr. Brooks (C+)
- Ocean's 13 (B+)
- Surf's Up (B)
- Hostel II (F)
- Nancy Drew (C)
- The Fantastic Four (C-)
- 1408 (A-)
- Evan Almighty (C+)
May 2007
- Hoax (B+)
- Amazing Grace (B)
- Next (C+)
- The Condemned (D-)
- Kickin' It Old School (F)
- Spider Man III (C-)
- Lucky You (B-)
- Wild Hogs (D)
- 28 Weeks Later (C+)
- Georgia Rule (D)
- Delta Farce (None)
- The Invisible (C)
- Fracture (B)
- Bug (C-)
- Pirates of the Caribbean III (C+)
April 2007
- Meet the Robinsons (B+)
- Shooter (C+)
- Blades of Glory (C)
- The Last Mimsy (C+)
- Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (C)
- The Hills Have Eyes II (D+)
- Are We Done Yet (F)
- The Reaping (D-)
- Firehouse Dog (C+)
- Disturbia (D)
- Pathfinder (D)
- Perfect Stranger (C-)
- Vacancy (C+)
March 2007
- Wild Hogs (C-)
- 300 (B+)
- The Number 23 (D)
- Zodiac (B)
- Premonition (B+)
February 2007
- The Messengers (C)
- Because I Said So (None)
- Norbit (None)
- Music and Lyrics (C+)
- Ghost Rider (D)
- Hannibal Rising (D)
- Bridge to Terabithia (A)
- The Astronaut Farmer (B+)
- The Abandoned (B-)
- Reno 911: Miami (D)
June 2006
- The Break Up (C-)
Alumni Relations Home

